Just Updated

U.S. troops who requested airstrike thought hospital was under Taliban control

U.S. troops who requested airstrike thought hospital was under Taliban control

the army Green Berets who requested the Oct. Three airstrike on the Doctors without boundaries trauma middle in Afghanistan have been conscious it Was Once a functioning hospital However believed it Was below Taliban keep an eye on, The Related Press has discovered.

The New knowledge adds to a body of proof that the internationally run scientific facility web site Used To Be familiar to the U.S. defense force, raising questions about whether or not the decision to assault it violated world legislation.

A day prior to an American AC-A Hundred Thirty gunship attacked the medical institution, a senior officer in the Green Beret unit wrote in a report that U.S. forces had mentioned the medical institution with the usa director of the medical charity Workforce, Presumably in Kabul, in step with two people who have seen the record.

The attack left a mounting loss of life toll, now as much as 30 individuals.

One After The Other, within the days prior to the assault, “an reputable in Washington” asked Docs borderless “whether our hospital had a large Crew of Taliban fighters in it,” spokesman Tim Shenk mentioned in an email. “We answered that this Was now not the case. We Additionally stated that we have been very clear with all sides to the battle concerning the need to recognize medical constructions.”

Taken together, the revelations add to the growing possibility that U.S. forces destroyed what they knew Used To Be a functioning health facility, which might be a violation of the global rules of struggle. The Pentagon has mentioned Americans would by no means have intentionally fired on a scientific facility, and it’s unclear why the green Beret unit requested the strike — and the way such an attack Was Once approved with the aid of the chain of command — on coordinates widely known to have incorporated a health center.

Although the U.S. believed the Taliban have been operating from the health center, the presence of wounded patients inside would have made an air attack on it challenging below standard American ideas of engagement and the world legislation of war.

Pentagon spokesman Maj. Roger Cabiness declined to respond to questions, saying in a commentary that it could be “untimely to attract any conclusions” before the three investigations into the assault are complete.

What we all know to this point

The U.S. has decided “that the stories of civilian casualties had been credible, and we continue to work with the federal government of Afghanistan to totally establish the victims,” stated Brig. Gen. Wilson Shoffner, a NATO spokesman, in a statement. U.S. and NATO investigations, he said, “continue to look at a collection of attainable human mistakes, screw ups of process and technical malfunctions that can have contributed to the unsuitable strike on the health facility.”

“MSF record that they have personnel in the trauma heart,” the Oct. 2 file by using a senior Green Beret officer from Third Different Forces Team mentioned, in step with two individuals who have considered it. MSF is the abbreviation for the Staff’s French identify, Medicins sans Frontiers. The report adds that the trauma heart Used To Be underneath the keep an eye on of insurgents, said the sources, who would now not be quoted with the aid of identify because they were not authorized to speak about it publicly.

The coordinates of the medical institution have been despatched to “all friendly forces,” the document stated, noting that among the U.S. objectives for day after today Used To Be to “clear the trauma middle” of enemy forces.

Docs without boundary lines officials say the clinic Was no longer below Taliban keep watch over and that no gunmen have been running from inside the compound — about six metropolis blocks square with the one-story hospital situated some two blocks again in the back of a 12-foot wall — when the AC-A Hundred Thirty gunship made five passes, firing for an hour.

Every Other health facility run by means of Afghanistan’s well being ministry, a brief distance away, had been overrun by using the Taliban when insurgents seized the city, a senior U.S. security official mentioned.

The Brand New knowledge raises the possibility that some components of the U.S. intelligence and military apparatus had perplexed the two hospitals. But other proof argues towards such confusion.

The AP has suggested that American Unique operations analysts were gathering intelligence on the Doctors without borderlines sanatorium, including indications it Used To Be being used by a Pakistani operative to coordinate Taliban job. The intelligence gathering befell because the U.S. Was Once supporting the Afghan effort to retake Kunduz, which integrated heavy preventing by using Inexperienced Berets.

the green Berets had requested for Air Power intelligence-gathering flights over the hospital, and both Green Berets and Air Power personnel have been conscious it Was a safe medical facility, the records show, in keeping with the 2 individuals who have seen the paperwork.

Afghanistan Bombed Hospital

The charred remains of the Docs without borderlines hospital is viewed after it Was hit through a U.S. airstrike in Kunduz, Afghanistan.

Picture: Najim Rahim /Associated Press

The analysts’ file included maps with the health center circled, along with indications that intelligence agencies have been monitoring the location of the Pakistani operative and process stories in line with overhead surveillance, in step with a former intelligence official who is familiar with one of the crucial paperwork. The intelligence prompt the medical institution Used To Be being used as a Taliban command and keep an eye on heart and can have housed heavy weapons.

After the attack, some U.S. analysts assessed it Used To Be justified, the records exhibit, and one file stated 16 enemies had been killed, the two sources say. These deaths were mentioned to incorporate the Pakistani, who the U.S. believed Was working for his u . s . a .’s Inter-Service Intelligence directorate.

No evidence has surfaced publicly suggesting a Pakistani died in the assault, and Medical Doctors without borderlines says none of its body of workers Used To Be Pakistani.

What we still have no idea

Gen. John Campbell, commander of american forces in Afghanistan, has said that “a different operations unit that Was Once in close vicinity … Was speaking to the plane that delivered These fires.”

A senior Green Beret officer has told superiors that his troops, accompanying Afghan security forces, have been beneath fire and in peril, according to a former govt respectable familiar with his account.

Doctors borderless denies that any fire Used To Be coming from its compound. And Even Though it Was Once, it’s uncertain why any U.S. forces outside Those partitions might now not have moved to safer floor.

Additionally a mystery is why the AC-130 gunship would have saved firing right through the direction of an hour on a building that each the Air Pressure and the military knew Was Once an internationally run trauma middle. To steer clear of civilian casualties, a gunship would generally stop firing as soon as it finished its function — on this case, ostensibly, defending U.S. forces. Most Often, the aircraft would require further clearance from the troops on the ground to proceed firing.

An AC-One Hundred Thirty gunship flies low and slow, ceaselessly with a excellent view of its goal and the injury it is inflicting. The pilot Also would have had to be aware of the locations of U.S. and allied forces within the area, to avoid hitting them.

Doctors borderless has mentioned it Used To Be frantically calling Kabul and Washington right through the attack, trying to make the U.S. privy to what Was Once unfolding as patients died in their beds.

Possibly, the gun camera video from the airplane would show whether or not any person Was Once firing from the medical institution. The U.S. government has but to make it public.

Supply hyperlink




Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published.